Best New York Whiskey

• Click here to browse our full list of reviews!

This list catalogs all of the whiskey from this region that we have reviewed so far, ordered by rating and price.

---

Advertisment

---

Dennings Point Distillery - Beacon Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $59.49

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Manhattan Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $53

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Maple Cask Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $53

Kings County Distillery - Peated Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $50

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Baby Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $46

Albany Distilling Co. - Ironweed Empire Rye Whiskey Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4.5) - $47.99

Tuthilltown Spirits - Do The Rye Thing Straight Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4.5) - $35.99

Black Button - Pre-Prohibition Style Straight Bourbon Whiskey Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4.5) - $?????

Good Shepherd - Sound Shore Single Malt Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $92

Kings County Distillery - Straight Bourbon Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $69

Albany Distilling Co. - Ironweed Straight Bourbon Whiskey Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $60

Still The One - 914 Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $39.99

High Peaks Distilling - Cloudsplitter Straight Single Malt Straight Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $?????

Kings County Distillery - 6-Year Blender's Reserve Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3.5) - $125

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Bright Lights, Big Bourbon Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3.5) - $46

Finger Lakes Distilling - McKenzie Rye Whiskey Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3.5) - $40.99

Long Island Spirits - Pine Barrens Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $93.98

Kings County Distillery - Wine-Finished Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $80

Widow Jane - Oak & Apple Wood Aged Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $50.99

Kings County Distillery - Grapefruit Jalapeno Flavored Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $49

Finger Lakes Distilling - McKenzie Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $41.99

Great Jones - Straight Bourbon Whiskey Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $41.99

Catskill Distilling Co - The Most Righteous Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $29.99

Widow Jane - 10 Year Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(2) - $69.99

Black Dirt Distillery - Crown Maple Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(2) - $41.45