Best New York Whiskey

• Click here to browse our full list of reviews!

This list catalogs all of the whiskey from this region that we have reviewed so far, ordered by rating and price.

Dennings Point Distillery - Beacon Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $59.49

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Manhattan Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $53

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Maple Cask Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $53

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Baby Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $46

Good Shepherd - Sound Shore Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $92

Still The One - 914 Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $39.99

High Peaks Distilling - Cloudsplitter Straight Single Malt Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $?????

Long Island Spirits - Pine Barrens Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $93.98

Widow Jane - Oak & Apple Wood Aged Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $50.99

Catskill Distilling Co - The Most Righteous Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $29.99

Widow Jane - 10 Year Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(2) - $69.99

Black Dirt Distillery - Crown Maple Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(2) - $41.45