Best Peanut Butter Whiskey Click here to browse our full list of reviews! This list catalogs all of the peanut butter whiskey that we have reviewed so far, ordered by rating and price. Advertisment Shepherd's - P'Nutty Peanut Butter WhiskeyFlavored Whiskey | United States, KentuckyRating:(4) - $19.99Skrewball - Peanut Butter WhiskeyFlavored Whiskey | United StatesRating:(3) - $25.99Ram's Point - Peanut Butter WhiskeyFlavored Whiskey | United States, KentuckyRating:(3) - $14.49Skatterbrain - Peanut Butter WhiskeyFlavored Whiskey | CanadaRating:(2) - $18.99Sheep Dog - Peanut Butter WhiskeyFlavored Whiskey | United StatesRating:(1) - $14.99Total Results: 5
