Best American Whiskey

This list catalogs all of the whiskey from this region that we have reviewed so far, ordered by rating and price.


Dennings Point Distillery - Beacon Small Batch

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(5) -
$59.49

Tahwahkaro - Four Grain

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(5) -
$54.99

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Manhattan Rye

Rye Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(5) -
$53

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Maple Cask Rye

Rye Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(5) -
$53

Few Spirits - Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Illinois

Rating:(5) -
$51

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Baby Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(5) -
$46

Spirit of Texas - Pfluger Single Malt Whiskey

Single Malt Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(5) -
$45

Still Austin Whiskey Co. - Straight Bourbon

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(5) -
$45

Still Austin Whiskey Co. - Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(5) -
$44.99

Oak & Eden - Rye & Spire

Rye Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(5) -
$39.99

Balcones - Texas Bock

Single Malt Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(5) -
$36.99

Balcones - Texas Pot Still

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(5) -
$?????

Four Roses - Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4.5) -
$28.99

Good Shepherd - Sound Shore Single Malt

Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(4) -
$92

Garrison Brothers - Texas Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$73.65

Copperworks Distilling Co - American Single Malt Whiskey

Single Malt Whiskey | United States, Washington

Rating:(4) -
$60

Balcones - Brimstone

Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$60

High West Distillery - Campfire

Blended Whiskey | United States, Utah

Rating:(4) -
$60

Old Forester - 1910 Old Fine Whiskey

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$54.99

Few Spirits - Rye Whiskey

Rye Whiskey | United States, Illinois

Rating:(4) -
$54.99

Yellow Rose - Outlaw Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$52.99

Ranger Creek - .36 Caliber Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$49.99

Stranahans - Colorado Whiskey

Whiskey | United States, Colorado

Rating:(4) -
$47.99

Austin 101 - Light Whiskey

Light Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$45

Fire Oak - Texas Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$44

Jack Daniels - Single Barrel Rye

Rye Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(4) -
$43.99

Lone Elm - Small Batch Texas Straight Wheat Whiskey

Straight Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$43.99

Kooper Family - Sweetheart of the Rodeo Straight Bourbon

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$39.99

Still The One - 914 Bourbon Whiskey

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(4) -
$39.99

Kooper Family - Rye

Rye Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$39.99

Balcones - Baby Blue

Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$36.99

Legent - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$36

Woodford Reserve - Distillers Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$33.99

Iron Wolf - Select Bourbon Whiskey

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$33.99

Jack Daniels - Tennessee Straight Rye

Straight Rye Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(4) -
$33

Treaty Oak - Red Handed

Blended Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$32

Makers Mark - 46

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$30.99

Buffalo Trace - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$30

Redemption - High Rye Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States

Rating:(4) -
$25.99

George Dickel - No. 12 Tennessee Sour Mash Whiskey

Tennessee Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(4) -
$25.99

BENDT Distilling Co - Bendt No. 5

Blended Whiskey | United States

Rating:(4) -
$25.49

Devils River - Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$24.99

Tincup - American Whiskey

Whiskey | United States, Colorado

Rating:(4) -
$24.99

Jack Daniels - Gentleman Jack

Tennessee Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(4) -
$23.99

Still Austin Whiskey Co. - Mother Pepper

Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$22.99

George Dickel - Classic No. 8 Tennessee Sour mash Whiskey

Tennessee Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(4) -
$22

Bulleit - Rye Whiskey

Straight Rye Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$21.99

Alamo Distilling Co - Alamo Bourbon Black Label

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(4) -
$20.49

Old Forester - 86 Proof

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$19

Jim Beam - Double Oak

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$18.99

Evan Williams - White Label

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$16.99

Evan Williams - Black Label

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$12

Evan Williams - Green Label

Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(4) -
$8.99

High Peaks Distilling - Cloudsplitter Straight Single Malt

Straight Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(4) -
$?????

Traverse City Whiskey Co. - XXX Straight Bourbon

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Michigan

Rating:(3.5) -
$45.99

Long Island Spirits - Pine Barrens

Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(3) -
$93.98

Widow Jane - Oak & Apple Wood Aged

Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(3) -
$50.99

Ironroot Republic - Promethean

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(3) -
$44.99

Woodford Reserve - Double Oaked Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$44

Jack Daniels - Single Barrel Barrel Proof Tennessee Whiskey

Tennessee Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(3) -
$43.99

Woodford Reserve - Distiller's Select Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey

Straight Rye Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$43.99

Mitcher's - US1 Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$40

Witherspoon - Texas Straight Bourbon

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(3) -
$38.92

Woodinville - Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Washington

Rating:(3) -
$38.49

Belle Meade - Sour Mash Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$34.99

Basil Hayden's - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$32.99

Catskill Distilling Co - The Most Righteous Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(3) -
$29.99

Bulleit - Bourbon

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$27.99

Makers Mark - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$25.99

Evan Williams - Single Barrel Vintage

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$25.99

Jack Daniels - Tennessee Sour Mash Whiskey

Tennessee Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(3) -
$21.99

Old Forester - 100 Proof

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$21.99

Jim Beam - Black

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$18.49

Old Grand-Dad - 80 Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$16

Oak Cliff - Texas Bourbon Whiskey

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(3) -
$15.49

J.T.S. Brown - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$13

Ezra Brooks - Kentucky Sour Mash Bourbon Whiskey

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(3) -
$11.99

Balcones - Texas High Rye

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(3) -
$?????

Treaty Oak - Ghost Hill Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(2.5) -
$43.99

Still Austin Whiskey Co. - Sherry Cask Finished Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(2) -
$90

Banner Distilling Co. - Wheat Whiskey

Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(2) -
$70

Widow Jane - 10 Year

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(2) -
$69.99

Old Forester - Statesman

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(2) -
$54.99

The Splinter Group - Slaughter House American Whiskey

Whiskey | United States

Rating:(2) -
$41.99

Black Dirt Distillery - Crown Maple Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York

Rating:(2) -
$41.45

Clyde Mays - Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States

Rating:(2) -
$37.99

Knob Creek - Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(2) -
$35.99

High West Distillery - American Prairie Bourbon

Blended Whiskey | United States, Utah

Rating:(2) -
$35

3 Howls - Backbeat Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Washington

Rating:(2) -
$29.99

Firestone & Robertson - TX Blended

Blended Whiskey | United States, Texas

Rating:(2) -
$29.98

Elijah Craig - Small Batch

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(2) -
$26.99

Wild Turkey - Bourbon Whiskey

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(2) -
$23

Cascade - Blonde

Whiskey | United States

Rating:(2) -
$20

Two Stars - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(2) -
$19.99

Sugarlands Distilling Co - Appalachian Apple Pie Moonshine

Moonshine Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(2) -
$19.99

Luxco - Rebel Yell

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(2) -
$18

Paddleford Creek - Small Batch Bourbon

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Minnesota

Rating:(2) -
$17.99

Jim Beam - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(2) -
$16.49

Luxco - Rebel Yell Ginger

Flavored Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(2) -
$11.99

Hayes Parker - Reserve Original Bourbon Whiskey

Bourbon Whiskey | United States, South Carolina

Rating:(2) -
$10.99

Seagram - Seven Crown

Blended Whiskey | United States

Rating:(2) -
$8.99

Kentucky Deluxe - Kentucky Blended Whiskey

Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(2) -
$5.99

Coville - Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(1) -
$40

Skrewball - Peanut Butter Whiskey

Flavored Whiskey | United States

Rating:(1) -
$25.99

Caliber Company Spirits - Classic

Flavored Whiskey | United States

Rating:(1) -
$21

American Born - Apple Whiskey

Flavored Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(1) -
$20.99

Old Crow - Straight Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(1) -
$14.49

McAfee - Benchmark Old No. 8 Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whis

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(1) -
$14

Jim Beam - Red Stag

Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(1) -
$12.99

Ancient Age - Preferred Blended Whiskey

Blended Whiskey | United States

Rating:(1) -
$6

Banker's Club - Blended Whiskey

Blended Whiskey | United States

Rating:(1) -
$6

Ole Smoky - Tennessee Salty Caramel Whiskey

Flavored Whiskey | United States, Tennessee

Rating:(0) -
$17.99

Barton Brands - Colonel Lee Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Straight Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky

Rating:(0) -
$8.99