Best American Whiskey

• Click here to browse our full list of reviews!

This list catalogs all of the whiskey from this region that we have reviewed so far, ordered by rating and price.

Dennings Point Distillery - Beacon Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $59.49

Tahwahkaro - Four Grain Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(5) - $54.99

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Manhattan Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $53

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Maple Cask Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $53

Few Spirits - Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Illinois Rating:(5) - $51

Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Baby Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $46

Spirit of Texas - Pfluger Single Malt Whiskey Single Malt Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(5) - $45

Still Austin Whiskey Co. - Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(5) - $44.99

Oak & Eden - Rye & Spire Rye Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(5) - $39.99

Balcones - Texas Bock Single Malt Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(5) - $36.99

Balcones - Texas Pot Still Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(5) - $?????

Good Shepherd - Sound Shore Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $92

Garrison Brothers - Texas Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $73.65

Copperworks Distilling Co - American Single Malt Whiskey Single Malt Whiskey | United States, Washington Rating:(4) - $60

Balcones - Brimstone Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $60

High West Distillery - Campfire Blended Whiskey | United States, Utah Rating:(4) - $60

Yellow Rose - Outlaw Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $52.99

Ranger Creek - .36 Caliber Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $49.99

Stranahans - Colorado Whiskey Whiskey | United States, Colorado Rating:(4) - $47.99

Fire Oak - Texas Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $44

Jack Daniels - Single Barrel Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, Tennessee Rating:(4) - $43.99

Kooper Family - Sweetheart of the Rodeo Straight Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $39.99

Still The One - 914 Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $39.99

Kooper Family - Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $39.99

Balcones - Baby Blue Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $36.99

Legent - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(4) - $36

Woodford Reserve - Distillers Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(4) - $33.99

Iron Wolf - Select Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $33.99

Jack Daniels - Tennessee Straight Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, Tennessee Rating:(4) - $33

Treaty Oak - Red Handed Blended Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $32

Makers Mark - 46 Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(4) - $30.99

Buffalo Trace - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(4) - $30

Redemption - High Rye Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States Rating:(4) - $25.99

Devils River - Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $24.99

Still Austin Whiskey Co. - Mother Pepper Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $22.99

George Dickel - Classic No. 8 Tennessee Sour mash Whiskey Whiskey | United States, Tennessee Rating:(4) - $22

Alamo Distilling Co - Alamo Bourbon Black Label Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(4) - $20.49

Old Forester - 86 Proof Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(4) - $19

Jim Beam - Double Oak Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(4) - $18.99

Evan Williams - White Label Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(4) - $16.99

Evan Williams - Black Label Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(4) - $12

Evan Williams - Green Label Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(4) - $8.99

High Peaks Distilling - Cloudsplitter Straight Single Malt Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(4) - $?????

Traverse City Whiskey Co. - XXX Straight Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Michigan Rating:(3.5) - $45.99

Long Island Spirits - Pine Barrens Single Malt Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $93.98

Widow Jane - Oak & Apple Wood Aged Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $50.99

Ironroot Republic - Promethean Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(3) - $44.99

Woodford Reserve - Double Oaked Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $44

Jack Daniels - Single Barrel Barrel Proof Tennessee Whiskey Whiskey | United States, Tennessee Rating:(3) - $43.99

Woodford Reserve - Distiller's Select Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey Rye Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $43.99

Mitcher's - US1 Kentucky Straight Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $40

Witherspoon - Witherspoon Texas Straight Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(3) - $38.92

Belle Meade - Sour Mash Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $34.99

Catskill Distilling Co - The Most Righteous Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(3) - $29.99

Bulleit - Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $27.99

Makers Mark - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $25.99

Evan Williams - Single Barrel Vintage Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $25.99

Jack Daniels - Tennessee Sour Mash Whiskey Whiskey | United States, Tennessee Rating:(3) - $21.99

Old Forester - 100 Proof Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $21.99

Jim Beam - Black Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $18.49

Old Grand-Dad - 80 Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $16

Oak Cliff - Texas Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(3) - $15.49

J.T.S. Brown - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $13

Ezra Brooks - Kentucky Sour Mash Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(3) - $11.99

Balcones - Texas High Rye Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(3) - $?????

Treaty Oak - Ghost Hill Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(2.5) - $43.99

Still Austin Whiskey Co. - Sherry Cask Finished Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(2) - $90

Banner Distilling Co. - Wheat Whiskey Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(2) - $70

Widow Jane - 10 Year Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(2) - $69.99

Old Forester - Statesman Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(2) - $54.99

The Splinter Group - Slaughter House American Whiskey Whiskey | United States Rating:(2) - $41.99

Black Dirt Distillery - Crown Maple Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(2) - $41.45

Clyde Mays - Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States Rating:(2) - $37.99

Knob Creek - Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(2) - $35.99

High West Distillery - American Prairie Bourbon Blended Whiskey | United States, Utah Rating:(2) - $35

Firestone & Robertson - TX Blended Blended Whiskey | United States, Texas Rating:(2) - $29.98

Elijah Craig - Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(2) - $26.99

Wild Turkey - Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(2) - $23

Cascade - Blonde Whiskey | United States Rating:(2) - $20

Two Stars - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(2) - $19.99

Luxco - Rebel Yell Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(2) - $18

Jim Beam - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(2) - $16.49

Hayes Parker - Reserve Original Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, South Carolina Rating:(2) - $10.99

Seagram - Seven Crown Blended Whiskey | United States Rating:(2) - $8.99

Kentucky Deluxe - Kentucky Blended Whiskey Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(2) - $5.99

Coville - Kentucky Straight Bourbon Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(1) - $40

Skrewball - Peanut Butter Whiskey Flavored Whiskey | United States Rating:(1) - $25.99

Caliber Company Spirits - Classic Flavored Whiskey | United States Rating:(1) - $21

American Born - Apple Whiskey Flavored Whiskey | United States, Tennessee Rating:(1) - $20.99

Old Crow - Straight Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(1) - $14.49

McAfee - Benchmark Old No. 8 Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whis Bourbon Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(1) - $14

Jim Beam - Red Stag Whiskey | United States, Kentucky Rating:(1) - $12.99

Ancient Age - Preferred Blended Whiskey Blended Whiskey | United States Rating:(1) - $6

Ole Smoky - Tennessee Salty Caramel Whiskey Flavored Whiskey | United States, Tennessee Rating:(0) - $17.99